No-Revisionist-History.org

Eminent Domain

Court Case Error

40-54A

161C

Notable EnviroCrime

How could this happen?

Eminent Domain
Click on the image above to go to a PDF of the story

The first example in the U.S. of a community using Eminent Domain to 'reassemble' former railroad corridor for the purpose of creating a public walking or biking pathway was in Falmouth and Woods Hole on Cape Cod, Massachusetts.

This was in the 1970s and it was a couple of years of court cases and appeals before it finally went before the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts.  See this great booklet published by the Woods Hole Historical Society that tells the largely forgotten story about the trials and tribulations of building a trail way back then when such a thing was a bit of a new fangled idea.  LINK HERE to the story.


More examples of Eminent Domain to create a public pathway
The City of  Northampton, Massachusetts has used eminent domain several times in the purchase of right-of-way easements and fee simple title from MassElectric (which had purchased the right-of way from Penn Central) and, in cases where title was not clear, from other private property holders. 
Sample takings (attached):
1. MassCentral Rail Trail in Leeds
2. MassCentral Rail Trail access ramp at Jackson Street
Hazardous Release Liability: Acquiring a right-of-way easement instead of fee simple title may protect cities from liability for existing releases of hazardous materials that are not made worse by the project.    

Examples of the legal documents
Here's a couple of Northampton examples on the Mass Central Rail Trail
Click on the image to go to a PDF of the file
Click on the image above to go to a PDF of the file
Here's an example in Marion on the South Coast Bikeway
Click on the image above to go to a PDF file.
 
The MBTA, the transit authority in and around Boston
Around the same time as the case on Woods Hole, the MBTA entered into an agreement with the Boston & Maine Railroad to purchase the B&M's existing operational commuter rail lines AND their dormant lines. 

These were two separate transactions and in both cases the MBTA used their "confirmatory takings" tool--their version of eminent domain-- to clear up any "cloudy" title. 

Today, 40+ years later, many of the communities hosting these forgotten corridors are in the process of building them out into linear parks.   Check out the lists which totals about 60 communities.

Click on the image above to go to a PDF file
Click on the image above to go to a PDF file
More examples are coming soon

 

Website powered by Network Solutions®